My 2.0 Beta 2 findings

I will be posting several posts on my 2.0 beta 2 findings here.

This first issue I posted on the open forum, but realized I should have posted it here.

After creating about 4 bullet/number lists with color only produced by FCKedit beta2 only, I ran the output through JTidy. I get:

line 1 column 1 - Warning: inserting missing 'title' element
line 1 column 286 - Warning: missing before <ul>
line 1 column 286 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 286 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 294 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 376 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 449 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 526 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 533 - Warning: replacing element by 
line 1 column 533 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 920 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 923 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 923 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 923 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 923 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 945 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 949 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 953 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 957 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 964 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 964 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 964 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 964 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 964 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,040 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 1,047 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 1,054 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 1,059 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 1,068 - Warning: replacing element by 
line 1 column 1,068 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 1,097 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,101 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,105 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,109 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,116 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,217 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,221 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,225 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,229 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,236 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,337 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,341 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,345 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,349 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,356 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,457 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,461 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,465 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,469 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,476 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,573 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 1,573 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,573 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,576 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 1,598 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,602 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,606 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,610 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,617 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,617 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,693 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 1,700 - Warning: replacing element by 
line 1 column 1,700 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 1,729 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,733 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,737 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,741 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,748 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,849 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,853 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,857 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,861 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,868 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,969 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,973 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,977 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 1,981 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 1,988 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,363 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,366 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 2,366 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 2,366 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 2,366 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 2,388 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,392 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,396 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,400 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,407 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,407 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,407 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,407 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,407 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,483 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 2,490 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 2,497 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 2,502 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 2,511 - Warning: replacing element by 
line 1 column 2,511 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 2,540 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,544 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,548 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,552 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,559 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,660 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,664 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,668 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,672 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,679 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,780 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,784 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,788 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,792 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,799 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,900 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,904 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,908 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 2,912 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 2,919 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,016 - Warning: missing before 
line 1 column 3,016 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,016 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,019 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 3,041 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,045 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,049 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,053 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,060 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,060 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,136 - Warning: discarding unexpected 
line 1 column 3,143 - Warning: replacing element by 
line 1 column 3,143 - Warning: inserting implicit 
line 1 column 3,172 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,176 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,180 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,184 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,191 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,292 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,296 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,300 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,304 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,311 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,412 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,416 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,420 - Warning: discarding unexpected p
line 1 column 3,424 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,431 - Warning: trimming empty 
line 1 column 3,507 - Warning: missing <li>
line 1 column 3,511 - Warning: missing <li>
line 1 column 3,515 - Warning: missing <li>
line 1 column 3,519 - Warning: missing <li>
line 1 column 3,523 - Warning: missing <li>

InputStream: Document content looks like HTML 3.2
167 warnings/errors were found!

Fri, 10/01/2004 - 15:25

jeichels

Joined: 06/10/2004

Posts: 17

RE: My 2.0 Beta 2 findings

Other findings:

Copy paste using cntl-C cntl-V seems to be giving odd results at times. For instance I can copy paste a list that is:
1. xxxx
2. yyyy
3. zzzz

and get after copy:
1.
2. xxxx
3. yyyy
4.
5. zzzz

Color fonts get messed up and such when they are applied at times or during copies.

Trying to get it to happen again, but somehow I was getting like hundreds of elements in a row between lists, but not sure how.

My "size" toolbox is pulling down briefly, but not allowing me to aply a size to text.

Is there a newer version of the tool I can mess with or download somehow? I am not seeing a "cvs" thing up top here.

Sat, 10/02/2004 - 12:42

jeichels

Joined: 06/10/2004

Posts: 17

RE: My 2.0 Beta 2 findings

I am very excited about one portion of FCKeditor at the moment. I just tried cutting and pasting a very complex Word document and it did a terrific job. The HTML produced looks just like the original document. I even think the markup produced from it was not so bad.

I know this because I have hooked up in the backend both JTidy and now NekoHtml. On those tools, I think it was easier (because of example) to get JTidy running, but I believe in the end NekoHtml has a far more powerful interface. They both seem to run about the same speed and produce similar outputs I think.

I think the one thing on markup that has me still concerned though I am not seeing it as badly as when I first started out is that for some reason tons of type tags were being produced and there seemed need for optimization. Not sure how you would go about doing this.

I agree that the "remove formatting" button is not working and also the "size" is not working for me.

If you have an update can you either email it to me or post it? I could really use some of this for my site in production.

Please email at jeichels@gmail.com if you can or else post here as a Beta 3? I know it is all a bit of work, but I am kinda excited and want to put this stuff out live after much more testing. :+)

JohnE