Multiple Toolbar Config's on a Page

Ok, this should be pretty easy, and I must be missing something here.

I have multiple textarea's on the page, with either 1 of 2 possible class names "basic" or "advanced".
I have my two Toolbar sets setup in the Config file, and then I'm calling this on the page to load CKE:

CKEDITOR.replaceAll('Basic',{toolbar:'Basic'});
   CKEDITOR.replaceAll('Advanced',{toolbar:'Advanced'});

This isn't working. If I have 'config.toolbar = 'Basic';' set in the config.js file, they're all Basic. If I remove that config setting, it defaults to NEITHER of my set Toolbar's, but to the Full one.

What am I missing here?