CKEditor 4 Skin Contest Winner!

New CKEditor 4 Skin

We are happy to officially announce the winner of our CKEditor 4 Skin Contest:

Winner:

Moono: Rafal Bromirski

Congratulations to Rafal Bromirski! His design has been selected as the default CKEditor 4 skin and Rafal wins $1000 in prize money!

Runners-up:

Ozone: Simon Sturmer


Congratulations also go to runner-up, Simon Sturmer, for his great looking skin, Ozone, and Aleksander Nowodziński for a solid entry with Silver. We also want to thank all entrants for making so many cool skins! The community will definitely benefit from your work, so don’t hesitate to share your skins.

CKEditor’s New Look

We wanted a professional but neutral toolbar to accommodate the widest range of websites. Of all the entries Moono, Ozone and Silver best offered what we were looking for: a professional, simple, clean skin that didn’t detract from the editing experience. We didn’t set out looking for a monochrome look but the best entries were monochromatic. Of the three, Moono stood out the most.

So here is it, the new CKEditor 4 skin, Moono:

In case you haven’t noticed, the final Moono is a bit different from the initial entry. Rafal complied with our wishes by giving us a lighter variation of his original dark skin, which is as good as the original.

Why Moono?

Making the final decision was tough but Moono barely beat Ozone for the ultimate prize (things will never be the same between the judges). As you can see above, what gave Moono the edge was the professional, clean, spacious look. When testing the entries on live pages it became clear that inline editing needed a slim toolbar to be out of the way. Skins with encumbered toolbars pulled the inline editing experience down. Moono’s smaller icons make the editing process more discreet.

Another plus was the original dark skin, which turned out to be a blessing in disguise. Even though the initial skin was good enough to represent our new default look, the inclusion a lighter design now gives the community two official versions of Moono made Rafal Bromirski! Of course, only one was chosen as the “default” skin and it was the light one.

Finally, of all the entries Moono got the biggest support from the community. You all made our tough decision that much easier in the end, so thank you all for making your voices heard!

What’s Next?

In the next few weeks we will be making a few more modifications to the skin before implementing it to the final release of CKEditor 4. Don’t expect an overhaul; it’s going to be the same skin but with a few changes.

Again, we want to thank everybody for participating. Making the final decision was not easy, not with so many good entries, so your feedback helped. You all did a great job and we are thankful to have such an active community!

We hope you like the new skin!

Enter the discussion and post your comment

Post a comment
  1. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
    • Yes, we'll keep that in mind. That was one of our concerns and why Ozone had such a strong chance to win. But since Moono's icons are custom we are planning on changing a few of them. If you feel some of them aren't clear, let us know. Now is the time before we release CKEditor 4!

      • I'm getting the feeling people are being influenced by the header pic with the colorful crayons. ;-) I agree, it looks great with all those cool colors. But let's not forget that website owners want an editor that can blend with their pages, and most sites have a main theme color, so adding nice colors will make it hard to please everyone.

    • We have to make a few modifications to the skin first. It's not 100% ready. As some have mentioned, it needs a bit of color, even if only to give users a point of reference when glancing at the editor. We haven't even determined who will make those changes, so be patient.

    • There will always be other skins available, other than the one we're choosen as the default. The CKEditor 3 Kama skin will still be there and there will be several other skins available, so you'll definitely have a choice.

    • We are working on pretty much eveything you mentioned. :) As for better page integration, check our current nightly build of v4. It shows how color is also added to the icons. We picked that particular skin because it's neutral. It least likely to bother people who don't wanto to personalize the editor.

  1. yea! I like the general look of the icons and skin, but hope you'll introduce some colour.

    thank post

  2. Great icons and toolbars I like the mono version more!